Mentoring vs. Induction Programs AED/201 April 10, 2011 Audrey E. Lane Mentoring vs. Induction Programs Many new teachers are not prepared when they enter the system as an educator. Some did not anticipate the heavy work load, low pay, stress or lack of resources that comes with teaching and as a result 15 percent of teachers leave the field after their first year (Kauchak). Some districts and states have come up with plans to help keep new teachers and lower that turnover rate. Two such programs are mentoring programs and induction programs. Many people confuse these terms or think they are the same, when in fact, they are very different. Mentoring means to serve as a trusted counselor or teacher to another person. A good mentor is a single person who is there for the new teacher to help them survive their first year in the field. The mentor should be available to help the new teacher overcome common obstacles such as lesson planning, disruptive students and teaching techniques. While mentoring is effective it does have its limitations; the mentor usually has their own responsibilities to take care of and time between the two teachers is often limited. Additionally, with only one source to turn to information may not always be accurate and feedback is not always provided. An induction program, on the other hand, is a process to help a new teacher not only survive in his or her environment but also to thrive in it. A good induction process can include a thorough orientation process, a highly qualified mentor, frequent reviews, and frequent meetings to discuss problems, a structured curriculum plan and time to observe senior teachers. Although this program may seem far superior it is also far more costly than a simple mentoring program. In order to determine which type of program is better we need to turn to the facts; mentoring focuses on survival while induction promotes professional development. Mentoring relies on a single person to provide an unbelievable amount of knowledge while induction offers several sources of support for the new teacher (Pan and Mutchler). In addition, mentor programs are generally for first year teachers only while induction programs last several years (Pan and Mutchler). Therefore, it is clear that, while mentoring is a beneficial and important part of a new teachers training, mentoring should be used in conjunction with an induction program to yield the best results. An extensive induction program helps to create and retain quality teachers. These programs set clear expectations and responsibilities for these new teachers. The programs provide ongoing support and development. While a mentoring program may utilize extra time for feedback and questions, an induction program sets aside a specific amount of time regularly for that purpose. Also, most mentoring programs provide mentors based on seniority or availability while an induction program only provides mentors who pass specific guidelines resulting in higher quality training. These types of programs came into widespread use in the early 1990’s and at that time 40 percent of new teachers were involved in one of these programs. Now over 80 percent of new teachers are involved in either an induction or mentoring program for their first one to three years of teaching (AASCU). A new study performed by the National Center for Education Statistics, Schools and Staffing shows a 50 percent improvement in attrition among teachers who participated in an induction program. In addition this study showed that although induction programs cost more money than mentoring alone, in the end induction programs brought in more than was invested (AASCU). There are no federal guidelines to ensure these programs are available to new teachers; instead that responsibility falls to the local state and district and, sadly, these programs are often forgotten. There are currently 30 states that have induction programs available and of those 30 only a few are mandated (Ladd, H.). Some require that the mentor and mentee have a minimum amount of time to meet while others require that both teachers teach in the same grade, school or subject (AASCU). Many states do not even require that the mentor be compensated for his or her work (AASCU). These programs are designed to enable new teachers, give them several resources to turn to and give them ample opportunity to thrive. New teachers who are able to participate in these programs can turn to their mentor and other school officials for help or advice. These teachers are able to improve themselves because they are provided with regular feedback. With all of these additional resources plus more these teachers can reach their full potential far faster than teachers without the program. This makes them stronger, more knowledgeable and more valuable assets to any school. By taking part in a mentoring or induction program as a paraprofessional I will be the mentee and I plan to use these types of programs to my advantage. I can work in a teaching environment alongside an experienced teacher so that I have a better understanding of the education field. I will be able to see the day to day tasks that need to be accomplished and how that experienced teacher accomplishes them. I will be able to obtain valuable teaching skills such as planning tips and control of the classroom before I am left to do it on my own. These programs are gaining popularity and there is no doubt that they are effective when implemented properly. However, the consistency and overall implementation of these induction or mentoring programs leaves much to be desired. These programs should be used by all schools in all states. Furthermore, these programs should be more strongly and equally mandated. In order to be successful these programs need to run for at least the first two years with new teachers, the mentors need to be top professionals and adequate time needs to be set aside for questions and planning. If these things can be accomplished equally across the nation, our teachers of tomorrow will be able to be better teachers faster, our children will have a higher quality education and our country can stop spending money to train new and inexperienced teachers by retaining the quality ones we have. References AASCU. (2006). Teacher Induction Programs: Trends and Opportunities. Retrieved on January 31, 2009 from American Association of State Colleges and Universities website; http://www. aascu. org/policy_matters/v3_10/default. htm Kauchak, D. & Eggen, P. (2005). Developing as a Professional. Retrieved on January, 31, 2009 from Introduction to Teaching: Becoming a Professional. Ladd, H. (2007). Teacher Labor Markets in Developed Countries. Retrieved on January 31, 2009 from;
Related Essay Samples
Food web diagram
The top of the desert food chain does eventually die though, and is returned to the bottom of the chain as nutrients by decomposers. These animals, including insects, mammals, such as the desert pocket mouse, food is consumed and converted ...
Marketing mix for samsung galaxy
And it has only gotten worse with the launch of the Galaxy SO and the ETC One. And while the Jury is still out on the camera, it's the overall usability of the marathoner that has won fans all over.
Organ transplants
According to Nora Machado, the commercialization of organ donation has a contradictory impact on public voluntarism and altruism, the risk of exploitation of the poor, and deprecates the main lesson of experts and standards of humanity by degrading the dignity ...
Marketing on can/should juniata college develop a masters level program in leadership for non-profit organizations
Information needs to be gathered from various quarters on the future of the program and the need for such a program. Information that reveals the demographic, socioeconomic, and psychological and lifestyle characteristics of the target market needs to be gathered.
5 ways to win sales and influence people
If you work in account management or in a typical sales job, you already know how hard it can be to make the same pitch repeatedly - to the point where you are not even sure whom you told and ...
Garment worker
The study attempts to explore the present socio-economic status of the garments workers. It was found that the socio-economic condition of the Garments workers is not in a lofty stage.
Free essay about a) the value of diversity from sociological perspective
I understand that the commitment to civic engagement lies on the bedrock of engaging the public and building sustaining relationship with the members of the community on matters that are pertinent to the locals. The charisma of the individual over ...
Admission essay on my motivations for becoming a physician assistant
At the moment I am 38 years old, born in Venezuela and I have a passion to extent a helping hand to those who are in need of personalized health care and medical attention is the primary motivation that has ...
Coding: an invaluable skill
This is because you need to learn one programming language which will enable you know the type of words to and not to use when coding. Example, if you play a video game and you think the game is below ...
Goal making in the professional world
A closer evaluation of the university's mission, stated as " The Master of Science in Medical Health Sciences prepares students for a successful career in the medical profession by enhancing their knowledge in the basic sciences and by providing an ...
Jc penney strategic case studies examples
JC Penney is one of the largest retail stores in the world. In 2011, JC Penney hired Ron Johnson, a former Apple employee, as the CEO of the company to revolutionize the brand.
Case study juwan howard
Boston: McGraw-Hill Case Study Juan Howard By Judaism different according to the national culture where the negotiation is taking place. Using the seven key steps to an ideal negotiation process that Greenshank suggests in the text book we will present ...
Diversity and inclusion an organization emperical study of hul (draft)
Diversity management is a strategic process to manage a diverse workforce-including the fight against stereotypes, prejudice and all kind of discrimination due to the individual perceptions and assumptions- in the manner to maximize the benefit and minimize barriers of different ...
Essay on growing up
The problems start when you let this obsession take over your life and soon everything you have worked so hard for slips away from what you thought was a secure mask, leaving you exposed to the world as your true ...
An analysis of kfc’s marketing mix
14 iii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Purposes of the report The main purpose of the report is to Analyze the marketing mix of KFC and perform a thorough market analysis by mainly targeting the youth through a consumer survey. The report is ...
Research paper on nursing legal and ethical issues in health occupations
Their specific function is to enhance health care delivery by working as a team in providing a variety of diagnostic, technical, therapeutic interventions These interactions forge direct approaches towards patient care functioning as delicate support system resources to the other ...
Introduction – objective of financial accounting essay
For instance, they will evaluate the financial performance of the company, assess the return derived from the investment, gauge the liquidity of the business enterprise and its ability to pay its long-term commitments, ascertain the capital structure of the firm ...
The concept of leadership in the media
Concept of Leadership Source Social responsibility FPAA summit emphasizes social responsibility http www.thepacker.com/news/fpaa-summit-emphasizes-social-responsibility For company sustainability, social responsibility plays a great part in improving reputation of the company in the society it requires the leaders to show direction for other ...
Internet banking in the sultanate of oman
Khalfan A With the advances in the information and technology sector, business and the market economy are changing tremendously. Bank Muscat is therefore enabled to manage delivery of personalised, tailored financial products and services over the Internet.
Case study on management and organizational behavior
The problems of the virtual team ranged from adapting the cultural model to lack of proper working relationships. Proper record of each meeting can be effective for collaborating team members and be used to identify the suitability between members.
Essay on trends
Infusing and augmenting involves creation of new products that retain a majority of an older product's attributes but incorporates some aspects of the emerging trends. This course has equipped me with the knowledge required to become an effective manager in ...
Example of term paper on cuba government and politics
The government is the overall owner of the means of production and ensures the masses share in the distribution of wealth. The power of the country was in the hands of a few rich people known as the elite.
Private vs. public: a better education?
But the question is, does public school really provide a better education, or is it just hype? Although private school has that small advantage over public school, it is not the determining factor in a " good education".
The this number could nearly double by 2019
With the latest marijuana news from California, the lawful recreational marijuana trade is poised to bring in millions of dollars in tax revenue. In addition to the economic benefits, the legal marijuana trade will also open the doors for new ...
Customer services at datatronics essay sample
EZ-RP was able to manage the profitable business in SME and it has made a name for itself in the world of business which had attracted the Datatronics to acquire and merge it in them. Customer service representatives First step ...